Joel Sherman’s smug assessment of the manner Mets’ trainer Mike Herbst managed Jon Niese’s injury yesterday was irresponsible, nescient and classic Monday morning quarterbacking. Says Sherman:
Some of the injuries are pure folly. Castillo, who has to dodge runners on double-play pivots, hurt himself on the dugout steps trying to avoid stepping on a glove. But you wonder if common sense could have saved the Mets yesterday.
Niese hurt himself stretching at first to try to complete a double play. Yet he convinced Jerry Manuel and trainer Mike Herbst that he just needed a second to catch his breath. Manuel requested that Niese be allowed to make a few practice pitches. No trainer asked him to exhibit strength or flexibility in the leg before attempting something athletic.
Joel, there’s likely to be not a trainer in the business who would not have done the same thing. Niese was on the field and not in the training room. A strength and flexibity assessment at that time might not have revealed anything. Niese had already shown pretty good flexibility in his stretch at first and he walked back to the mound on his own. A functional test was in order as its the best test to assess any injury.
Niese tore one of the proximal hamstring tendons off his pelvis on that unfortunate overstrech covering 1st base. He did not make it worse on the test. We make the athlete do functional tests to see if they can continue. When a pitcher is assessed on the mound for a problem, we do not spend any time trying to stretch something or do a manual test as it doesn’t tell us anything. We have them throw.
The inferrences by the NY print media of the manner in which the Mets training staff have done their jobs is unprecedented in its unfairness and its lack of educated perspective. As the Mets’ trainers are not allowed to talk to the media, print media like Sherman have been irresponsible and unprofessional by not getting clarification on topics they know nothing about.
Posted under Uncategorized
This post was written by bobsikes on August 6, 2009
Tags: Athlete, Cheap Shots, Clarification On, Common Sense, Double Play, Dugout Steps, Flexibility, Folly, Functional Test, Functional Tests, Joel Sherman, Jon Niese, Manual Test, METS, Mike Herbst, Monday Morning Quarterbacking, Pelvis, Runners, Tendons, Unfairness