The former govenor is not alone in his own party. Partisan Republican group think seeks to impose their all-knowing take on education based on cherry-picked data from his own foundation and feel good platitudes.
Govenor Bush continues to grip tightly to the notion that the FCAT – a one day assessment that was intended to measure acheivement levels is an end all in measuring learning “gains”. Utilization of the FCAT remains his primary justification for the advancement of his party’s agenda. This would be just a simple-minded embarrassment for a public servant of magnitude if it weren’t so demonstrably wrong. Yet the fervor that his agenda is advanced by an entire political party creates a never ending train wreck for the education of America’s children.
It is the FCAT that Jeb Bush continues to insist we accept as the end all to make all of our decisions regarding education. Pay no attention to evidence that FCAT is proving harmful or ineffective. Lets catalog a few.
1. Students have failed FCAT time and time again, even while they, their schools, teachers and families know they need it to graduate. Some 3000 south Florida HS seniors may fail to graduate as they did not score hig enough on FCAT retakes. Bush would have you believe that this simply means that blame needs to be placed on these student’s teachers.
2. Only 16% of Florida’s 22,000 seniors who retook FCAT reading passed. Only 28% of 8600 seniors whom retook FCAT Math passed. This is a bitter pill for these students knowing that this was at least the third time they took the test. Never mind the fact that both No Child Left Behind (Bush)and Race to the Top (Obama) see 100% graduation as the goal and that such a standardized test as the solution. But it’s the teachers fault you see.
3. Many don’t realize that a significant number of these same students will substitute a passing grade on the ACT or SAT – both college entrance exams – for the FCAT to graduate. Some 130 HS Seniors from the Treasure Coast graduated in 2008 because of accpetable scores on the ACT or SAT. They’re passing a college entrance test, but not the FCAT? This fact alone begs for further assessment of using FCAT as any kind of assessment tool.
4. FCAT Reading scores in Florida have been on decline. One look at the numbers of the counties with the highest percentages of students accepted by colleges – Santa Rosa, Sarasota, Martin and St. Johns showed passing rates of 10th grade reading of 47%, 43%, 50% and 53%. Only half of 10th graders? Bush would have us assume somehow that these rates indicate teachers are somehow at fault and that some should even be fired. Bush furthermore would have us believe that somehow the FCAT is working.
The first two in the above lists use stories released over the past few days and Bush’s op-ed piece looks desperate in it’s attempt to put FCAT in a glowing light. Bush’s study used teachers who’s students made the highest gains on FCAT. The observations they make about effective teachers are one’s that any teacher, parent or student could come up with. Yet Bush’s use of FCAT indicates that he would have us believe that only teachers who’s kids have done well on the FCAT can actualize such lofty ideals.
Still despite mounting evidence to the contrary, Bush maintains that FCAT scores are up and that the measures he advanced during his govenorship and his championing of SB6 are right for education.
Perhaps it is the fact of the matter that it is not only educators whom realize the folly in the use of standardized tests in general and the FCAT in particular. The lesson of SB6 should serve as a teachable moment for Jeb Bush and his acolytes in the Florida legislature.
Opposition to the bill could not have been more broad. The cynical among the Republican Party unfortunately still choose to see Charlie Crist’s SB6 veto and gubernatorial candidate Paula Dockery’s opposition as pandering to the teacher’s union when the public at large are now distrustful of unions.
This continued spin and delusion on the part of the Republican Party and pols like Jeb Bush on education only serves to harm the conseravtive movement. The administration of SB6 could have not been more contary to conservative principles. The manner in which it was advanced through both Florida legislative houses was earily similar to the way Obamacare was shoved through in Washington.
So perhaps it is the naysayers amongst Republicans like Dockery that thoughtful conservatives in the state should be paying more attention to. The fact that Charlie Crist leads a three-way race in some polling data indicates that some conservatives were turned off by the hysterical hostility heaped upon him by many GOP Florida legislative leaders. Republicans cannot be alienating conservatives, but their shrill rhetoric and flawed justifications and methods regarding education issues are doing just that.
Posted under EDUCATION, FLORIDA POLITICS
This post was written by bobsikes on May 23, 2010